A 3-3 Vote Leaves Southwest Harbor Subdivision Changes in Limbo
just now
The Bar Harbor Story is generously sponsored by Birch Bay Retirement Village.

SOUTHWEST HARBOR—Ben “Lee” Worcester asked to combine two lots and change the sewage and wastewater to individual septic systems rather than being on town sewer for his Trundy Farm Road subdivision.
That request before the town Planning Board resulted in a split 3-3 vote.
Another change was simply to put two fire hydrants on locations on the Trundy Farm Road, which was suggested by Southwest Harbor Fire Chief Thomas Chisholm.
Under the proposal, the subdivision would keep 12 lots, which was the original and previously approved number. However, two lots would be combined. Another would be split.
“Although we knew the public sewer would be an expensive project, but in aggregate, we thought it would be less. Well, as it turned out, no. In aggregate, the private septic tanks are predicted to cost less,” Worcester said.
The reason for changing the sewer systems for any potential residences in the subdivision from public to private came down to money.
“The total cost of providing public sewer outweighed the benefit,” Worcester said.
However, some Planning Board members worried that the proposed changes to the subdivision, which is close to a state-designated Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) uncontrolled site would disturb the soil more than hooking into the town’s system and that it might impact the surrounding groundwater.
“That means we’re disturbing the ground on those lots,” board member Priscilla Ksionzyk said.
Others argued it would be just pulling the top layer off.
There was then discussion about exactly what putting in individual septic systems and leach fields entailed when put into lots and whether it would disturb soil. In November 2025, Southwest Harbor voters approved soil testing for land uses within a half-mile of the uncontrolled sites, 554-187.
“I worry about the leach field leaching further beyond all the boundaries of your properties and the abutting properties,” Ksionzyk said.
Worcester said a good portion of the town is already using septic tank and leach fields.
Some board members were concerned about the change because the subdivision had previously been approved for the town sewer system which is a closed system.
While one board member said the requested change wouldn’t have impacted the subdivision’s approval, another member said they would not have agreed to it had it been presented that way.

During public comment, former Select Board member and the town’s representative to the Acadia Disposal District, Jim Vallette spoke to test results that he’d recently received from Maine DEP, which showed extremely high levels of PFAS—commonly known as forever chemicals that are toxic—in the Marshall Brook area.
The samples showed per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) this year as well as a decade ago. Some chemicals were not detected 10 years ago—perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA)—and are now at 42.8 parts per trillion.
Combined, the PFAS measurements, increased 110 parts per trillion from 17. State drinking water levels allow for 20 parts.
The worries for Vallette and others is that construction within a half-mile of the site could disturb soils that might contain toxins. Those toxins, they reason, could hurt people in their town. There has been some PFAS detected in some areas of the subdivision’s soil as well, Vallette said.
“So, in the course of 10 years (of) that surface contamination, there’s a seepage area of the landfill—that kind of faces the subdivision, drains into that leachate ditch that forms the western boundary of the subdivision,” Vallette said. “That’s been moving, with all this inaction from the state and the town, honestly. That, during that time … that plume of contamination has intensified considerably.”
Planning Board Chair Eric Davis said that Vallette’s public comments needed to relate to just the changes in the plan.
Vallette reasoned that they did. He also stressed that the town itself did not receive notice in August 2025 because “at that time the applicant changed the configuration of the lots in the middle of the application and the Planning Board agreed, there were no abutters other than the family members of the applicant and its related entities.”
Without abutters receiving status during the application, the original approval should be null and void, he said.
Sustainability Committee Chair Craig Kesselheim said via Zoom that he worried about the attitude of some board members acting as friends to the applicant—who was until recently on the Planning Board—as opposed to acting as Planning Board members.
“It feels like you’re finding ways to give your friend permission to go ahead with his proposed changes, as opposed to doing your job, which is to ask critical questions and look at flaws in a proposal,” he said.
He also asked when they should ask the town’s code enforcement officer about worries in the proposal because he hasn’t heard that yet.
“There is PFAS in the soil, so I’m asking you to do your job. This feels like money over public safety and public health. Mr. Worcester has explained to you several times tonight that this is a financial decision, not an environmental decision, not a public health and safety decision and I take issue with that,” Kesselheim said. “On behalf of my townspeople and the folks who have to live with the soil and water quality. So that’s a big concern for me about your action as a board who represents the townspeople, not the developers, but the townspeople of Southwest Harbor. So I’d ask you to do your job.”
Charlotte Gill, Ksionzyk, and John Williams voted against the change. Davis, Joel Wolak and David Lloyd voted in favor.
The next step will be for the board to reach out to an engineer about leach field and septic systems on the properties and any potential impact on any potential contamination.
LINK TO LEARN MORE
HELP SUPPORT THE BAR HARBOR STORY
When we started The Bar Harbor Story, we didn’t know if anyone would read it. But you showed up. You shared. You sent tips. Now—6,500 subscribers and over 400,000 views every month later—it’s clear: people here care about their community and each other.
We’ve kept everything free because news should never be out of reach, but every one of our stories takes time to write, and your support keeps The Bar Harbor Story going.
If you value our work, please consider a paid subscription, a founding membership, or a sponsorship.
It truly helps us cover one more meeting, tell one more story, shine one more light.
Even $5 a month makes a difference. Click here to become a one-time supporter now.
Thank you so much for being here.
Founding member information can be found here.
Have questions about sponsorships? Just send Shaun an email at sfarrar86@gmail.com, he’d love to hear from you.
Help us keep bringing you free, daily local news for you and our community. We appreciate it so much!
Make a monthly donation
Make a yearly donation
Choose an amount
Or enter a custom amount
Your contribution is appreciated.
Your contribution is appreciated.
Your contribution is appreciated.
Discover more from Bar Harbor Story
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
