“We Cannot Afford to Miss Another Season”: 187 Days After Judge Walker’s Decision, Businesses Hope Council Will Take Cruise Ship Action. Councilors acknowledged the need to move discussions forward while pointing to related litigation and pending decisions

“We Cannot Afford to Miss Another Season”: 187 Days After Judge Walker’s Decision, Businesses Hope Council Will Take Cruise Ship Action.

Councilors acknowledged the need to move discussions forward while pointing to related litigation and pending decisions

Carrie Jones

just now

Woman speaking into a microphone at a community meeting, with attendees seated behind her.
Amanda Gallant at Town Council Chambers, November 17.

The Bar Harbor Story is generously sponsored by the Maine Seacoast Mission.

Maine Seacoast Mission fundraising banner featuring a navy 1905 baseball cap and a $19.05 donation message for its 120th year

BAR HARBOR—Multiple business owners and residents asked the Town Council for both clarity and action on how the town allows cruise ships.

Approximately 30 members of the public attended the November 17 meeting with many members going to the microphone to spend an allotted three minutes each to implore the Council to hear their worries and concerns.

After a decision by Judge Lance Walker earlier this year that declared the town’s voter-approved ordinance unconstitutional in all months except for July and August, the town has taken no action nor accepted any new reservations.

For many of the people who spoke that gives them lack of clarity for the upcoming year as well as worries about what they characterized as a decreasing daytime revenue that had been bolstered by cruise ship passengers.

“I have a very small staff of year-rounders and we only close for about a month and a half or so every year. Ever since the decline in cruise ships, that time has gotten larger. It used to be just like five weeks. There was a time we didn’t even close,” Amanda Gallant, Dog and Pony Tavern’s co-owner said. “But it got bigger and bigger because that revenue that we’re not getting from those cruise ships has impacted us significantly. I employ family members, some of my closest friends. They’re people that have been with us for a long time. And so, it’s nice to be able to give them that security of knowing that coming back next year or having a year-round job is going to be there for them. So, I encourage you guys to take the steps forward to start making some reservations and work out something so that we can bring some cruise ships. I’m not asking for the world, but you can tell the difference immediately on the days that we have cruise ship people in town. It’s such a significant difference. It’s worth us talking about and communicating about.”

The town’s ordinance does not allow more than 1,000 disembarkations per day without fines. It also changes how the disembarkation process works, changing it from a license to a permit. That change has created other lawsuits involving the town and notice of violations for the property where cruise ships disembark.

After Walker’s ruling that the ordinance was not constitutional during those summer months, the Town Council issued a statement saying it would not allow new advance reservations by cruise ships “until a regulatory tool to manage disembarkation is enacted and the ongoing litigation is resolved.”

While the councilors have met with attorneys during closed executive sessions, which are not open to others, there hasn’t yet been any public-facing discussion or proposed regulatory changes.

Bald man in glasses and a nautical Hawaiian shirt reads from a paper at a microphone in a crowded classroom or meeting room.
Darrin Stavnesli

Darrin Stavnesli, Maliseet member and Mainer, year-round Bar Harbor resident who co-owns The Maine Store, was one of the first to speak.

He said he’s owned a business since 1997 and has been a cruise ship passenger.

“I’ve stated several times at several meetings, nothing will be said here tonight to change anyone’s feelings about cruise ships. I will, however, speak some truth. People ask me all the time what it means to be a Mainer. And for my childhood in the county, that’s Northern Maine for you folks from away, it meant hard work and an attitude of ‘you do your thing, I’ll do my thing and as long as your thing doesn’t hurt me or take money away from me, we can be friends and neighbors,’” Stavnesli said. ‘“I love that phrase, ‘friends and neighbors,’ because the quality of life crowd loves to say that. They also like to say, ‘We all want what’s best for Bar Harbor.’ That is a lie. Compromise is what is best for any situation with opposite opinions. And we’ve been offering compromises for years. So, some folks want no ships at all. That’s the compromise. And that’s not compromise. That is NIMBY, narcissistic selfishness.”

“Let me clear up some misconceptions about cruise ship passengers. For those of you who’ve never been on a ship, and for those of you who do not operate a tourism based business, I’ve been a cruiser and small business owner since 1997, so I have a little bit of knowledge on the issue. The absence of cruise ship passengers is a tangible loss of income to local small businesses. My wife and I sell only domestic products, several of them from local artists on the island. To buy more from them, we need people to buy from us. That is Business 101. My wife and I are also the staff, two of us, every day from April 1st to the PJ sale. Would we love to hire help? Absolutely. But we need customer traffic to do that. Cruise ship passengers are motivated. They’re only in port for a short period of time. They do not contribute to the parking issues. They are more friendly and polite than your average August visitor. They spend way more money than the average August visitor and way, way, way more than locals. I’ve noticed people referring to studies that reinforce their anti-cruise-ship position. One even suggested there wasn’t a shoulder season anymore. I love when people who don’t know show that they don’t know. Moving forward on reservations is necessary, and if I’m not mistaken, which I’m not, the town was presented with an amazing plan years ago to achieve a scaled down visitation schedule, which was a compromise for both sides of this issue. Spoiler alert, you shot that down and you disbanded the committee. If we’re all friends and neighbors, why would you make efforts to hurt your friends and neighbors? Why do you feel your quality of life is more important than mine? If this Council really cares about what’s best for Bar Harbor, please consider opening up the cruise ship reservations immediately. Thank you for your time,” Stavnesli said.

Stavnesli and Gallant weren’t the only ones who told the Council that despite positive sales tax data, their businesses were suffering this season where roughly 12 ships (with pre-existing reservations) visited.

Woman speaking into a microphone at a community meeting with seated attendees and a chalkboard behind her.
Kristi Bond

Kristi Bond, co-owner of FishMaine Restaurant Group, said the difference during the day when cruise ships were in port, was easy to see. Like many, she also spoke to how she lived in Bar Harbor year round and that she has kids in its schools.

“Please start scheduling cruise ships for the 2027 season. It is virtually impossible to run a business or make a plan when you can’t see what is happening in the future. And it’s so important for all of us and our employees to be able to make that happen,” Bond said. “I think it’s also imperative that you all understand how much cruise ships truly affect a typical day in Bar Harbor. And I know you’ve heard everyone here say that, but when I looked at the 12 days of the year that we had cruise ships this year, between the hours of 11 a.m. and 4 p.m. at my restaurants, we served 81% more people on a cruise ship day than on a non-cruise ship day. And I’m not talking weeks away from each other. I’m comparing Tuesday to Wednesday of the same exact week.”

She employs approximately 35 year-round locals.

“We’re not just business owners, we’re residents. We live here. This is how we make our life and our livelihood. And to have an 81% difference in one day to the other is huge and makes a drastic difference in the way that we are able to run our business.”

Bond also spoke to the Bar Harbor Historical Society’s recent quick release of all its employees, referring to the decision as part of a “trickle-down” effect of less cruise ship passengers which equalled less revenue for the Society, which is housed in LaRochelle, a museum that offered tours during the season for fees as well as hosting free community, local-oriented events and collections.

Man speaking into a microphone during a meeting in a classroom with seated attendees
Loren Hubbard

Loren Hubbard, co-owner of Little Village Gifts, and who has owned Bar Harbor businesses for 36 years, said the councilors were creating “a perpetual cycle of uncertainty.”

He said it’s putting the taxpayers at financial risk.

“I am here to ask the Council to move forward and stop the obstructionism. We are months into planning and ordering for our upcoming season. Yet we are being held financially, emotionally, and decision-making stuck in a perpetual cycle of uncertainty,” Hubbard said.

Uncertainty is the opposite of what business owners need, he explained.

“Our employees, everyone involved in the downtown business community already knows the impact this ban has had. The time is now to decide whether you wish to continue putting this town, its taxpayers, in serious financial risk, spiraling upward with damages reaching well into the tens of millions. The time is now to be honest, upfront with the taxpayers of the financial risk you all are choosing for us. Please act now and make meaningful changes before the business community has no other choice but to advance other more costly lawsuits towards the town. Please remember, we’re all year-round business owners and year-round residents,” Hubbard said.

Hubbard also had strong words for some councilors.

“I find it shameful that we’ve had a couple counselors up here who have continuously attacked the business community and claim they are not year-round residents. They’re not year-round families. They’re here to grab the money bag and leave. And I’m looking at a very specific counselor because it’s been destructive to everybody. And we all answer for those comments every single day. Stop and start bringing this community back together,” Hubbard said.

Woman in a cream sweater seated among attendees at a public meeting
Older man speaking at a microphone before an audience in a classroom or meeting room
Jeff Dobbs

Former Councilor Jeff Dobbs said that he’d been on the Town Council when the town had decided that cruise ship revenue and visits would be good for the town. Cruise ships pay fees to the town when they visit. This creates revenue which impacts the town budget. Most of the revenue raised in the town budget comes from property taxes. Those bills continue to rise.

Dobbs said he hoped that the Council would work out a compromise that is fair to both business and nonbusiness people.

Older man speaking into a microphone at a community meeting while holding a smartphone, with an audience seated behind him.

Patrick O’Sullivan, said it was his seventh season working in Bar Harbor.

“I love Maine and Bar Harbor more than any place else I’ve lived in the world,” he told councilors.

He said, “The great state of Maine uh land area wise is 10% bigger than my homeland Ireland yet has less than quarter the population. I can’t help smiling to myself when I hear Mainers complain about congestion and overcrowding. The closest thing I’ve seen to congestion in Bar Harbor is in the 5 to 7 p.m. time frame when tourists from outlying hotels come into town for dinner and shopping after cruise ship passengers have already left. The quietest I’ve seen it in town is on fine weather daytimes when we don’t have a cruise ship and tourists go into the park.”

For O’Sullivan it makes a difference in his income as a tip worker.

“It’s been my experience over the course of seven seasons that cruise ship passengers are the single greatest source of daytime revenue in town. And not just for restaurants, but for clothing and souvenir businesses. Because of the shortage of local labor, business owners uh in town are forced to invest in costly and time-consuming government visa worker programs that raise labor costs astronomically. These workers are often idle during daytimes with no cruise ships and it is a much needed income stream to defray those labor costs. As a tip worker, my income is more than doubled on a cruise ship day. Also, this is a revenue source that is easily controlled by the harbor master and local authorities to avoid overcrowding and congestion on any given day,” O’Sullivan said.

Man in a red shirt and glasses speaks to a seated audience in a classroom with a projection screen and chalkboard.
Larry Sweet

Larry Sweet, former owner of Oli’s Trolley, a tour business, told councilors he was upset by the cruise ship ordinance’s impacts.

“I am deeply disappointed my hard-earned tax dollars have been spent defending this poorly conceived rule. And I’m equally disappointed I had to spend my hard-earned income defending my former business enterprise against it,” Sweet said.

Sweet spoke of Judge Walker’s decision as an opportunity “to craft a way forward on an exit ramp from this expensive and unending controversy.

“It is past time for the council to seize that opportunity, end this stain on our community and demonstrate leadership by reaching a solution where everyone can be equally disappointed yet can learn to live with,” Sweet said.

Duncan Holly, a tour operator from Mount Desert said the one thing he’s asking for is communication.

“There’s been silence for a half a year since the most recent ruling. And I have staff, dozens of them, that want to know if they have a job next year and I can’t tell them,” he said.

Woman speaking into a microphone at a crowded public meeting while holding handwritten notes.
Val Peacock

Near the end of the public comment, former Town Council Chair Val Peacock said, “I think you heard a lot tonight about people saying that they want the Council to have a plan. They want the Council to compromise. They want the Council to listen. And I think the Council does listen and is listening, but what’s really happening is that the town is not listening to each other.”

The Council, she said, is caught in the middle.

“You can listen to someone and make them feel heard and still disagree,” she said.

Peacock didn’t say what forum that would occur at. However, the Bar Harbor Chamber of Commerce is hosting a forum on cruise ships, tonight, November 18, at 5:30 p.m. at the Jesup Memorial Library.

Chamber Director Everal Eaton said during the Council meeting that everyone is welcome.

He said in an email, “Our goal for Wednesday’s Cruise Ship Community Forum at the Jesup Memorial Library is simple: to bring neighbors, business owners, and community leaders together for a constructive, good-faith discussion about cruise tourism and what’s best for Bar Harbor’s future. The Chamber represents hundreds of local businesses and community members who care deeply about this town. We believe the best path forward comes from listening to a wide range of perspectives and advancing the conversation. Every voice matters in shaping our town’s future. We welcome all, regardless of where they stand on the issue, to join us, share their thoughts, and be part of the solution.”

Woman in a cream sweater seated among an audience at a public meeting
Gail.

Gail, who didn’t give her last name, is a server in Bar Harbor.

“There is a big difference in the income,” she told councilors, between when cruise ships are here and when they aren’t.

Jeff Young, co-owner of Side Street Cafe, the Annex, and Acadia Gem asked the Council for multiple actions.

“Please direct the staff to begin accepting and processing cruise ship reservations,” he said.

He also called for less division in the community.

“The petition, the conflict surrounding it have created enough dissension and division in our small, tight-knit community. It’s time to reunite as the amazing community we’ve always been. The ruling, the cap is very clear. It’s unconstitutional except for July and August,” Young said. “Let’s reassemble the cruise ship committee, restore the collaboration that helped build this and manage this season over roughly 25 years. Let’s bring the crews. Let’s bring the cruise lines, the towns, the business people, the residents, fire department, hospitals together. Make sure that our community is safe while welcoming the visitors with open arms who have supported us and our livelihoods.”

Man wearing a baseball cap and glasses speaks to a seated audience in front of a chalkboard.
Jeff Young

Young continued, “Hardworking local businesses have suffered enough and so have their employees. Fewer customers means fewer shifts, less income, and greater difficulty paying everyday bills. There are enough challenges and uncertainties in this world right now and we should be working locally to ease our neighbors financial challenges and not adding to them through continued delay. We cannot afford to miss another season. So, please bring people back together and let’s get back to business.”

Eben Salvatore, of Ocean Properties, which is the owner of the disembarkation location, similarly implored the councilors to take action.

“It’s been 187 days since Judge Walker ruled,” Salvatore said. “The Council put out a statement five days later said you guys would be immediately beginning work on an approach to managing tourism from cruise ships. I think you’re hearing it’s time, right?”

There were eight days where a 4,000-passenger cruise ship visited this fall, he said.

“We’re patiently waiting. It’s been a long summer. Next summer looks terrifying. There’s not a ship booked,” he continued. “You can hear how much, how much that’s going to hurt people. We have a ruling. It’s clear.”

He advocated setting new limits for 10 months of the year, creating a schedule and moving forward.

“We’ve done this for decades. It’s the one part of our tourism that we can manage. We can negotiate. We can work with them. We can coordinate with them. It’s the easiest thing to do,” he said.

Man speaking into a microphone while holding notes at a community meeting, with seated attendees and a projection screen behind him.
Eben Salvatore

He worried that if the town continued to walk slowly toward a resolution there wouldn’t be any large cruise ships again until 2028.

“The nonprofits are suffering. You know, god forbid if the hospital has to make cuts because their revenue is down, which we know it is. The cruise ship people aren’t here. They’re not making ambulance calls. So, it’s just it’s going to continue to ripple through all the corners of our community until we get together and fix it,” he said adding to his earlier statement of “Let’s stop the pain.”

Shawn Porter, co-owner of Little Village Gifts, said she’d come to the meeting to get clarity.

“There’s been a lot of time and energy spent by you all and so many others to get to this point and I feel we need to work toward a common sense compromise for everyone. Unless you’re living it, you may not understand the importance of cruise ship business and how it supports us in very specific ways,” Porter said. “When I was a server, it made a lunch shift worth showing up for in the fall. Now, as a store owner, cruise ship business allows me to open earlier in the spring and extend later into the fall. That helps not only me, but also keeps my staff employed longer. There is a balance, and I believe we all know that. I truly just want the best for the entire town, but we need to start somewhere soon.”

Older man in glasses reading from a paper at a public meeting, with a microphone and seated audience nearby
Tom Testa

Tom Testa used his time to push back on the notion that due to sales figures since the cap, the town’s tourism businesses are seeing higher profits.

“This is a very flawed notion to conflate gross sales with visitor volume or somehow business help. Sales tax is a percentage of gross sales and as prices rise due to inflation, so does sales tax revenue based on gross sales,” Testa said.

It’s a yearly event, he explained.

“This is in no way indicative of any visitor volume, business health. We’ve seen general inflation nationally on a larger scale, closer to home within the state, new taxes, higher electric rates. Locally, higher property taxes, increased water rates, combined with increased payroll costs, insurance costs, costs of goods sold, and you can bet there’s a lot more coming in the next year,” Testa.

For businesses to remain viable, he said, they have to cover these costs. To do so, they increase prices. That increases gross revenue figures.

“This kind of misapplication of data would be like saying my grocery bill is higher this year, there must be more people grocery shopping,” he said. “Additionally, no one makes mention of the large number of lost non-taxable sales like museums and tour operations as well as wholesale sales like agency liquor stores that sell products to bars, restaurants, and hotels for resale. All of these have been significantly impacted by this ordinance. It’s surprising that the sales tax increases as a percentage of gross sales is not higher. This tells us that businesses are trying to stay ahead of inflation, if at all, and being mindful of what customers can afford.”

That’s the reality behind those numbers he said.

“You may not like economic realities, but economic realities always win. Economic realities always bat last and bat a thousand. Misleading the public with reliance on sales tax figures, I’ll put it kindly, is fallacious and disingenuous, and it needs to stop,” Testa said. “There’s a problem. You can help us fix it.”

Woman speaking into a microphone while holding a smartphone at a public meeting, with an audience seated behind her.
Lizz Sturm

Lizz Sturm, the CEO of Oli’s Trolley, shared the impact of her business this season.

“I was able to increase our donations to nonprofits, which as many have mentioned are being impacted. As a business owner, we get to reinvest back into our community. So any way that we can grow our businesses helps increase that. I was also able to create two year round jobs where I’m paying somebody even though I don’t have any tours going,” she said. “That was based off of the growth and the work we did continuing the previous owner’s vision. We want to continue that growth and continue that ability.”

She said they’d also helped people find housing, help cover part of housing costs, partnered with other local businesses, and drove revenue back into the town between different restaurants, different shops, while sharing what makes Bar Harbor special.

“We also took time and redid our gift shop and we reinvested into Maine creators, designers, suppliers carrying now local businesses, even two from here in Bar Harbor and our gift shop and getting those outside guests and visitors to see what is remarkable about Bar Harbor,” she said. “To be able to plan and continue this growth and this impact in the community, we need that communication. That’s what I’m here advocating for because I want to continue that impact and doing more good in the community that we serve as a business.”


COUNCIL COMMENTS

Bearded man in a navy sweater vest and white shirt seated in front of gray curtains
From top left, clockwise: Town Manager James Smith, Deb Vickers, Maya Caines, Steven Boucher

As is policy, councilors did not respond to the public comment immediately after the comments, but multiple councilors spoke toward cruise ships at the end of the meeting during the “councilor comments” portion of the agenda. Much of the public had already left.

“We’ve gotten the emails. We saw the room tonight. Whether you’re left, right, up, down, your opinion on more boats, less boats, whatever, we as a group, we need to expedite this. We need to have a conversation. We need to move this along. We need to provide guidance. So, I look forward to doing that with the rest of you,” Councilor Steven Boucher said.

Immediately following him, Councilor Deb Vickers agreed.

“We need to move forward I feel, expeditiously, but we need to hear everybody whether you agree or not. Listen and communicate,” Vickers said.

“On a positive note, we can all do this,” she said.

Vice Chair Brechlin said he worried about misinformation being presented in public comment.

He said that Judge Walker’s decision didn’t say that the town couldn’t regulate cruise ships for ten months of the year, but that it couldn’t cap it at 1,000 disembarkations for those months.

“I want to find a compromise. I think we can. I mean, the idea that we’re somehow going to salvage the 2027 season. The cruise companies book two years out and the fact that they’re not booking, that’s something. You need to have that conversation. And as far as Council foot dragging, I can’t argue that we couldn’t have moved a little faster. But at the same time, there’s other court cases related to this particular issue. And the decisions of those court cases and the appeal periods that have to play out inform our decisions and what our next steps are, too. So, it’s not all being done in a vacuum,” Brechlin said.

Councilors David Kief and Joe Minutolo had no comment. Councilor Randell Sprague was absent.

Older man sitting in a black chair, holding eyeglasses near his face.
From top left, clockwise: Joe Minutolo, David Kief, Eben Salvatore, Val Peacock

Chair Maya Caines read a statement that she said was based on what councilors had been hearing in the past few weeks. It had been written prior to the meeting.

“Many of these concerns that were coming up around cruise ships that we’ve heard in emails and that we heard tonight are based on misunderstandings of the town’s position,” Caines said.

“The town has not, we have as a Council have not, prohibited cruise ships from visiting Bar Harbor. We’re still accepting applications for disembarkation permits. However, the town’s practice of providing advanced anchorage confirmations without the required disembarkation permits first being issued had changed. Um the federal court’s ruling limited enforcement to the 1,000 passenger cap outside of July and August, which Earl just mentioned, but it didn’t eliminate the town’s permitting requirements. Cruise ship operators can still apply for permits to disembark and the town cannot issue permits that haven’t been applied for. And they haven’t. A lot of this uncertainty that we’re hearing is because cruise ship operators and their local partners have challenged the town’s authority to regulate passenger disembarkation while also asking the town to confirm anchorage reservations in advance. These positions are difficult to reconcile.”

Caines said it was clear to her that they need to move forward developing a framework that works alongside Judge Walker’s ruling.

“James, I’m asking on behalf of the Council that the staff bring some data and additional materials around visitation to discuss at the upcoming December meeting. But in the meantime, the existing permitting process remains available. The responsibility to apply for permits lies on the local facilities that want to disembark cruise ship passengers and not the town Council.”


FORUM DETAILS

Poster for a community forum on the return and future of cruise tourism in Bar Harbor, featuring a cruise ship and the date Nov. 18th.

​Event Details

  • ​Date: Wednesday, November 18, 2026
  • ​Time: 5:30 PM – 7:00 PM
  • ​Location: Jesup Memorial Library (34 Mt Desert St)
  • ​Format: In-person
  • ​Admission: Free and open to all Mount Desert Island residents, business owners, and employees

Agenda​

  • 5:15 PM – 5:30 PM | Arrival & Welcome
    • Doors open early for sign-in and informal greeting.
  • ​5:30 PM – 5:50 PM | 2026 Season in Review
    • Chamber presentation outlining operational highlights from the 2026 cruise season, including passenger numbers, tender operations, downtown foot-traffic patterns, and economic metrics.
  • 5:50 PM – 6:20 PM | Looking Ahead: 2027 & Beyond
    • A guided presentation on upcoming schedule projections, evolving regulations, passenger service caps, and long-term infrastructure considerations for Mount Desert Island.
  • ​6:20 PM – 6:55 PM | Community Open Discussion & Feedback
    • Facilitated floor discussion open to all attendees. Participants are invited to share observations from the past year, voice concerns, and propose priorities for future season planning.
  • ​6:55 PM – 7:00 PM | Next Steps & Adjournment
    • Summary of key community input and details on how feedback will be shared with town committees and council members.

​Advance Registration & Submissions
​While registration is not required to attend, RSVPing helps us ensure adequate seating. If you would like to submit a question or topic for the panel to address during the Q&A segment, please submit it via email to events@visitbarharbor.com by Monday, November 16.


LINKS TO LEARN MORE

Cruise Visitor Survey

More information and link to register

To watch the meeting


HELP SUPPORT THE BAR HARBOR STORY

When we started The Bar Harbor Story, we didn’t know if anyone would read it. But you showed up. You shared. You sent tips. Now—6,500 subscribers and over 400,000 views every month later—it’s clear: people here care about their community and each other.

We’ve kept everything free because news should never be out of reach, but every one of our stories takes time to write, and your support keeps The Bar Harbor Story going.

If you value our work, please consider a paid subscription, a founding membership, or a sponsorship.

It truly helps us cover one more meeting, tell one more story, shine one more light.

Even $5 a month makes a difference. Click here to become a one-time supporter now.

Thank you so much for being here.

Founding member information can be found here.

Have questions about sponsorships? Just send Shaun an email at sfarrar86@gmail.com, he’d love to hear from you.


Discover more from Bar Harbor Story

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply